The Kelley House sits on Water Street in the heart of Edgartown, in a historic complex of inn buildings, cottages and gardens that has welcomed visitors for generations. The location puts you a minute from the harbor, the ferry to Chappaquiddick and the village's best shops, galleries and restaurants. The property has a courtyard feel, with brick paths, flower beds and a pool in season, and its rooms range from simple inn rooms to larger suites and cottages. The decor is traditional New England, with painted wood, patterned fabrics and comfortable beds, and the buildings reflect different eras of the village's development. Because the grounds are in the middle of town, the atmosphere can be lively in summer evenings, and the walk to dinner is short. Check the property page for current room types, amenities, pool season and pet policies.
This is a smart choice for travelers who like to be in the middle of things. You can leave the car behind, walk to the lighthouse in the morning, shop and dine in the village and return for an afternoon by the pool. Families and groups will find that cottages and connecting rooms offer more flexibility than a standard hotel room, but they book early for summer.
Peak season means higher rates, and light sleepers should ask for rooms away from the street or courtyard bar areas. Shoulder-season visits bring lower prices and a quieter village, though some services shorten their schedules. Ask about parking in advance, as it is limited in downtown Edgartown.
Honest limits
Older buildings have quirks, from uneven floors to compact bathrooms, and noise can carry. Amenities vary by room type, so confirm what is included. For a central, historic base in Edgartown at a more moderate price than the grandest waterfront hotel, it is a dependable pick.
A few practical details are worth raising before arrival. Ask whether your room is in the main building, a cottage or an annex, since views, noise and access differ. If you plan to bring bicycles, confirm storage arrangements, and if you travel with a pet, check the policy early because rules vary by room. The harbor is only steps away for morning walks, and Main Street restaurants fill up at dinner in summer, so book tables early. Winter and early spring operations may be limited, so confirm opening dates.
Neighborhood context helps too
The Old Whaling Church, the town's galleries and the harbor wharves all sit within a few blocks, and on summer evenings there is often live music or street activity close by. Staying midweek improves your chance of a quieter experience and a better rate, and a late-spring stay trades beach weather for fewer crowds and long, light evenings.
Why stay here
- ✓Central Water Street location
- ✓Walk to harbor and lighthouse
- ✓Courtyard gardens
- ✓Seasonal pool
- ✓Cottages and suites
- ✓Traditional New England decor
- ✓Near Chappaquiddick ferry
- ✓On-site dining nearby
Good questions
Is it close to the Chappaquiddick ferry?+
Yes, the On Time ferry is a short walk away.
Does it have a pool?+
A seasonal pool is available. Confirm opening dates when you book.
Is parking available?+
Parking in downtown Edgartown is limited. Ask the property in advance.